Why Allocate Minimum Pages Binary Search on Answer in DSA Python?

The Big Idea

What if you could find the fairest way to split tasks without trying every single option?

The Scenario

Imagine you have a stack of books to divide among a few students. You want to give each student a continuous set of books so that the student who gets the most pages has as few pages as possible. Doing this by guessing and checking every possible way manually would take forever!

The Problem

Trying every way to split the books manually is slow and confusing. You might miss better ways or spend hours checking all possibilities. It's easy to make mistakes and hard to know if your answer is the best one.

The Solution

Using binary search on the answer lets you quickly guess the minimum maximum pages a student can get. Then you check if that guess works by dividing the books. This method finds the best answer fast and without missing any possibilities.

Before vs After

✗ Before

max_pages = sum(books)
for guess in range(max(books), max_pages + 1):
    if can_divide(books, students, guess):
        return guess

✓ After

low, high = max(books), sum(books)
while low < high:
    mid = (low + high) // 2
    if can_divide(books, students, mid):
        high = mid
    else:
        low = mid + 1
return low

What It Enables

This approach lets you find the best way to split work or resources quickly and confidently, even when there are many possibilities.

Real Life Example

Think about dividing chapters of a textbook among study groups so that no group has too much reading. Using this method helps assign chapters fairly and efficiently.

Key Takeaways

Manual checking of all splits is slow and error-prone.

Binary search on the answer guesses and checks efficiently.

This method quickly finds the minimum maximum pages per student.

Practice

1. What is the main goal of the Allocate Minimum Pages problem when using binary search on the answer?

easy

A. To find the minimum maximum number of pages assigned to a student

B. To maximize the total pages assigned to all students

C. To find the maximum number of students that can be assigned books

D. To minimize the total number of books assigned

Solution

1. Step 1: Understand the problem goal

   The problem aims to allocate books to students such that the maximum pages assigned to any student is minimized.

2. Step 2: Clarify the binary search target

   Binary search is used on the range of possible maximum pages to find the smallest feasible maximum.

3. Final Answer:

   To find the minimum maximum number of pages assigned to a student -> Option A

4. Quick Check:

   Minimum max pages = goal [OK]

Hint: Focus on minimizing the largest pages any student gets [OK]

Common Mistakes:

• Confusing total pages with maximum pages per student
• Trying to maximize pages instead of minimizing
• Ignoring the binary search on answer approach

2. Which of the following is the correct way to initialize the binary search boundaries for the Allocate Minimum Pages problem given an array pages of book pages?

easy

A. low = sum(pages), high = max(pages)

B. low = max(pages), high = sum(pages)

C. low = 0, high = max(pages)

D. low = 0, high = sum(pages) * 2

Solution

1. Step 1: Determine minimum and maximum possible max pages

   The minimum max pages is at least the largest single book (max of pages), and the maximum is the sum of all pages if one student gets all books.

2. Step 2: Set binary search boundaries accordingly

   Set low = max(pages) and high = sum(pages) to cover all feasible max page values.

3. Final Answer:

   low = max(pages), high = sum(pages) -> Option B

4. Quick Check:

   Boundaries = max and sum [OK]

Hint: Low starts at max single book, high at total pages sum [OK]

Common Mistakes:

• Setting low to 0 which is invalid
• Swapping low and high values
• Using arbitrary high value instead of sum

3. What will be the output of the following code snippet?

def is_possible(pages, students, mid):
    count = 1
    total = 0
    for p in pages:
        if total + p > mid:
            count += 1
            total = p
            if count > students:
                return False
        else:
            total += p
    return True

pages = [10, 20, 30, 40]
students = 2
mid = 50
print(is_possible(pages, students, mid))

medium

A. True

B. None

C. SyntaxError

D. False

Solution

1. Step 1: Trace the allocation with mid = 50

   pages=[10,20,30,40], students=2: count=1, total=0 - p=10: total=10 <=50 - p=20: total=30 <=50 - p=30: 30+30=60 >50 -> count=2, total=30 - p=40: 30+40=70 >50 -> count=3 >2 -> return False

2. Step 2: Check if count exceeds students

   Count reaches 3 > 2, so return False.

3. Final Answer:

   False -> Option D

4. Quick Check:

   Allocation not possible with mid=50 = False [OK]

Hint: Check if books fit in mid pages per student [OK]

Common Mistakes:

• Miscounting students needed
• Adding pages incorrectly
• Confusing > and >= in condition

4. Identify the bug in the following code snippet for the Allocate Minimum Pages problem:

def allocate_pages(pages, students):
    low = max(pages)
    high = sum(pages)
    result = 0
    while low <= high:
        mid = (low + high) // 2
        if is_possible(pages, students, mid):
            result = mid
            low = mid + 1
        else:
            high = mid - 1
    return result

medium

A. The high pointer should move to mid - 1 when allocation is possible

B. The low pointer should move to mid + 1 when allocation is possible

C. The low pointer should move to mid when allocation is possible

D. The low pointer should move to mid - 1 when allocation is not possible

Solution

1. Step 1: Understand binary search update rules

   If allocation is possible at mid, we try to find smaller max pages by moving high to mid - 1. If not possible, we increase low to mid + 1.

2. Step 2: Identify incorrect pointer update

   The code incorrectly moves low to mid + 1 when allocation is possible instead of high to mid - 1, which searches larger values instead of smaller.

3. Final Answer:

   The high pointer should move to mid - 1 when allocation is possible -> Option A

4. Quick Check:

   Move high down when allocation succeeds [OK]

Hint: Move low up only when allocation fails, else move high down [OK]

Common Mistakes:

• Swapping low and high updates
• Not updating pointers correctly causing infinite loop
• Returning wrong result due to pointer errors

5. Given the books with pages [12, 34, 67, 90] and 3 students, what is the minimum possible maximum number of pages assigned to a student using binary search on answer?

hard

A. 67

B. 113

C. 90

D. 34

Solution

1. Step 1: Set binary search boundaries

   low = max(pages) = 90, high = sum(pages) = 203.

2. Step 2: Check feasibility at mid values

   Try mid = (90+203)//2 = 146: count=1, total=0 - p=12: total=12 <=146 - p=34: total=46 <=146 - p=67: total=113 <=146 - p=90: 113+90=203 >146 -> count=2, total=90 count=2 <=3, possible -> try smaller max Try mid = (90+145)//2 = 117: count=1, total=0 - p=12: total=12 <=117 - p=34: total=46 <=117 - p=67: total=113 <=117 - p=90: 113+90=203 >117 -> count=2, total=90 count=2 <=3, possible -> try smaller max Try mid = (90+116)//2 = 103: count=1, total=0 - p=12: total=12 <=103 - p=34: total=46 <=103 - p=67: 46+67=113 >103 -> count=2, total=67 - p=90: 67+90=157 >103 -> count=3, total=90 count=3 <=3, possible -> try smaller max Try mid = (90+102)//2 = 96: count=1, total=0 - p=12: total=12 <=96 - p=34: total=46 <=96 - p=67: 46+67=113 >96 -> count=2, total=67 - p=90: 67+90=157 >96 -> count=3, total=90 count=3 <=3, possible -> try smaller max Try mid = (90+95)//2 = 92: count=1, total=0 - p=12: total=12 <=92 - p=34: total=46 <=92 - p=67: 46+67=113 >92 -> count=2, total=67 - p=90: 67+90=157 >92 -> count=3, total=90 count=3 <=3, possible -> try smaller max Try mid = (90+91)//2 = 90: count=1, total=0 - p=12: total=12 <=90 - p=34: total=46 <=90 - p=67: 46+67=113 >90 -> count=2, total=67 - p=90: 67+90=157 >90 -> count=3, total=90 count=3 <=3, possible Try mid = (90+89)//2 = 89 (low > high, stop) Minimum max pages = 90

3. Final Answer:

   90 -> Option C

4. Quick Check:

   Minimum max pages = 90 [OK]

Hint: Binary search between max single book and total pages sum [OK]

Common Mistakes:

• Choosing max single book as answer without checking feasibility
• Not updating low and high correctly during binary search
• Misallocating books to students during checks