Amazon Leadership PrinciplesSignal: "I noticed" -> "I proposed a cross-team solution" -> "I quantified impact" -> "I managed trade-offs"

Tell Me About a Time You Proposed an Idea That Was Much Larger Than Expected - Amazon LP Competency

Propose and drive scalable, self-initiated solutions beyond scope.

Choose your preparation mode3 modes available

Competency STAR Evaluate

📌

Definition

Think Big means proposing and driving ideas that extend beyond immediate scope and short-term fixes, aiming for significant long-term impact. The core test is whether the candidate identifies opportunities that others miss and scales solutions beyond their own team or project.

⚡

Core Signal

Did the candidate identify and pursue a solution that was significantly larger in scope and impact than expected or assigned?

🏢

Company Framing

Amazon expects Think Big to manifest as owner-driven initiatives that fix root causes and create scalable, long-term solutions rather than patching symptoms or delivering incremental tweaks.

🚫

What It Is NOT

Completing assigned tasks well - that is execution, not Think Big
Suggesting small incremental improvements without broader vision
Waiting for permission or direction before acting
Focusing only on short-term gains or quick fixes
Confusing volume of work with scale of impact

✅

Candidate explicitly states they noticed a problem outside their assigned scope and took initiative without being asked.

"I noticed""wasn't on my sprint""nobody had flagged it"

Shows self-initiated ownership and proactive identification of opportunities beyond immediate responsibilities.

Common Miss My manager mentioned it might be worth looking into

✅

Candidate describes proposing a solution that impacts multiple teams or the entire organization.

"I proposed a cross-team solution""scaled this to multiple services""impacted the entire product line"

Demonstrates thinking beyond narrow boundaries and aiming for broad, scalable impact.

Common Miss I fixed a bug only in my team's codebase

✅

Candidate quantifies the impact of their idea in terms of business metrics or customer experience improvements.

"reduced latency by 30%""saved $50K per quarter""improved customer retention by 5%"

Quantification proves the idea was big and meaningful, not just conceptual.

Common Miss It made things better

✅

Candidate explains trade-offs and risks they managed when pushing a big idea forward.

"I pushed back on sprint priorities""managed risk by prototyping first""balanced short-term delays with long-term gains"

Shows mature judgment and ownership of consequences, critical for Think Big at Amazon.

Common Miss I just did it without consulting anyone

✅

Candidate highlights how their idea prevented future problems or created reusable frameworks.

"added monitoring to prevent recurrence""built a reusable component""designed for future scalability"

Indicates long-term thinking and systemic impact rather than one-off fixes.

Common Miss I fixed the immediate issue quickly

✅

Candidate uses first-person singular consistently to describe their role in ideation and execution.

"I proposed""I led""I drove the design"

Confirms individual ownership and contribution, avoiding dilution of credit.

Common Miss We did it together

💡

Depth Tip

Spend about 70% of your answer on the Action section, detailing your specific steps and decisions. Limit Situation and Task combined to 50 seconds max to maximize time for demonstrating ownership and impact.

❌ Manager-Assigned Initiation

"My manager suggested I look into this since I had bandwidth"

Ownership is binary - self-initiated or not. Manager-assigned = execution. No excellent execution recovers an assigned story.

DetectionAsk yourself: Would I have done this if my manager said nothing? If no, find a different story.

FixI noticed X while doing Y. Nobody had filed a ticket. I decided to act because...

❌ Scope-Limited Impact

"This was a bug only in my team's codebase and I fixed it quickly"

Think Big requires impact beyond immediate team or task. Single-team fixes are execution, not Think Big.

DetectionCheck if the story involves cross-team or long-term impact beyond your immediate scope.

FixI proposed a solution that scaled to multiple teams and prevented future issues.

❌ Vague Impact Claims

"It made things better"

Unquantified or vague impact fails to prove the idea was truly big or meaningful.

DetectionLook for specific metrics or business outcomes in the story.

FixI reduced latency by 30%, saving $50K per quarter and improving customer satisfaction.

❌ Group Credit Dilution

"We did it together"

Dilutes individual ownership and contribution, making it impossible to assess candidate's role.

DetectionListen for first-person singular statements describing candidate's actions.

FixI led the design and drove the implementation of the solution.

❌ Short-Term Fix Focus

"I fixed the immediate issue quickly"

Think Big requires long-term, scalable solutions, not just quick patches.

DetectionCheck if candidate mentions preventing future problems or scaling the solution.

FixI designed a reusable framework that prevents this class of issues going forward.

🚩 Passive Voice Throughout

"The problem was identified"

Candidate was spectator not actor. Passive strips agency from every action.

FixUse active voice: 'I identified the problem and took action.'

🚩 Overuse of 'We' Without Clarification

"We worked on the solution"

Obscures candidate's individual contribution, making ownership unclear.

FixSpecify your role: 'I led the design and coordinated with the team.'

🚩 Lack of Quantified Impact

"It helped the team a lot"

Fails to demonstrate the scale or significance of the idea.

FixProvide metrics: 'It reduced errors by 40%, saving 10 hours per week.'

🚩 Rambling Without Structure

"So, basically, I did a bunch of things and then it worked out"

Makes it hard to follow candidate's ownership and impact.

FixUse STAR format with clear Situation, Task, Action, Result.

🚩 No Mention of Trade-offs or Risks

"I just implemented it immediately"

Suggests lack of mature judgment, which weakens Think Big signal.

FixExplain how you balanced risks and benefits before acting.

🎯

Direct Triggers

Tell me about a time you proposed an idea that was much larger than expected.
Describe a situation where you thought big and influenced multiple teams.
Give an example of when you identified a problem no one else saw and solved it at scale.
Have you ever driven a project that went beyond your immediate responsibilities?

🔍

Indirect Triggers

Describe a time you improved a process that impacted other teams.
Tell me about a time you took initiative without being asked.
Give an example of when you balanced short-term needs with long-term goals.
Have you ever challenged the status quo to create a better solution?

👁

How to Recognize

Keywords: without being asked, beyond your role, proactively, scaled solution, long-term impact, cross-team, prevented future problems.

⚠️

Do Not Confuse With

OwnershipOwnership is about self-initiating and owning the problem end-to-end; Think Big focuses on the scale and vision of the idea.

Deliver ResultsDeliver Results is hitting a committed goal under pressure; Think Big is about proposing and driving larger-than-expected ideas.

Bias for ActionBias for Action emphasizes speed and decisiveness; Think Big emphasizes scope and long-term impact.

❓

How did you convince others to support your big idea?

Probes: Candidate's influence and leadership skills in scaling the idea.

❌ Weak

I just told my manager and they approved it.

Passing responsibility to manager shows lack of personal influence and ownership.

✅ Strong

I prepared a data-driven proposal highlighting business impact, addressed concerns proactively, and collaborated with key stakeholders to align priorities.

""I brought a data-backed proposal and aligned stakeholders to drive adoption.""

❓

What risks did you consider before pushing your idea forward?

Probes: Candidate's judgment and ability to balance trade-offs.

❌ Weak

I didn't think much about risks; I just wanted to move fast.

Ignoring risks shows immature decision-making, which weakens Think Big signal.

✅ Strong

I identified potential delays to other projects, mitigated by prototyping first, and communicated trade-offs to leadership to get buy-in.

""I balanced risks by prototyping and communicating trade-offs upfront.""

❓

How did you measure the impact of your idea after implementation?

Probes: Candidate's focus on results and data-driven evaluation.

❌ Weak

We got positive feedback from users.

Vague feedback lacks quantification and business translation.

✅ Strong

I tracked key metrics like latency reduction by 30%, cost savings of $50K per quarter, and improved customer retention by 5%.

""I quantified impact with clear business metrics and customer outcomes.""

❓

What would have happened if you hadn’t proposed this big idea?

Probes: Candidate's understanding of the counterfactual impact and urgency.

❌ Weak

Someone else probably would have fixed it eventually.

Downplays candidate's unique contribution and impact.

✅ Strong

Without my fix, the issue would have caused $8K weekly losses and customer complaints for months before being addressed.

""Without my fix, the problem would have cost thousands weekly and hurt customers.""

Amazon

Think Big

Amazon looks for long-term thinking - fix root cause not just symptom. Candidates must articulate scalable solutions and trade-offs explicitly.

Signal: I also proposed adding X to prevent this class of problem in future services.

Example QTell me about a time you proposed an idea that was much larger than expected.

What Elevates

Name the trade-off: I pushed sprint item back 2 days. Cost of inaction ($8K/week) exceeded cost of delay. Amazon credits candidates who articulate the trade-off explicitly and show ownership of long-term impact. This demonstrates mature judgment and aligns with Amazon's leadership principles.

Google

Think Big

Google values moonshot thinking and technical innovation that can impact billions. Emphasize creativity and technical depth in scaling ideas.

Signal: I designed a novel algorithm that improved scalability by 10x across global data centers.

Example QDescribe a time you proposed a solution that scaled to millions of users.

What Elevates

Highlight technical innovation and how you overcame complexity to deliver a scalable solution that aligns with Google's mission. Provide concrete examples of the technical challenges and your creative solutions.