Practice
n into at least two positive integers such that the product of these integers is maximized. Which algorithmic approach guarantees finding the optimal solution efficiently?Solution
Step 1: Understand problem structure
The problem requires maximizing product by splitting an integer into parts, which naturally fits a DP approach where subproblems represent maximum product for smaller integers.Step 2: Evaluate options
Greedy (always cutting 3s) fails on some inputs; brute force recursion is correct but inefficient; divide and conquer without memoization repeats work. Bottom-up DP tabulation efficiently computes all subproblems and combines results.Final Answer:
Option C -> Option CQuick Check:
DP tabulation ensures optimal substructure and overlapping subproblems [OK]
- Believing greedy always works for integer break
- Ignoring memoization in recursion
dp[3] after the outer loop iteration i = 3 completes?
def integer_break(n):
dp = [0] * (n + 1)
dp[1] = 1
for i in range(2, n + 1):
max_product = 0
for j in range(1, i):
max_product = max(max_product, max(j, dp[j]) * max(i - j, dp[i - j]))
dp[i] = max_product
return dp[n]
print(integer_break(4)) # Output not asked here
Solution
Step 1: Trace dp for i=2
dp[1] = 1 (given). For i=2, j=1: max_product = max(0, max(1,1)*max(1,1)) = 1, so dp[2] = 1.Step 2: Trace dp for i=3
j=1: max_product = max(0, max(1,1)*max(2,dp[2])) = max(0,1*2) = 2 j=2: max_product = max(2, max(2,dp[2])*max(1,dp[1])) = max(2,2*1) = 2 So dp[3] = 2.Final Answer:
Option A -> Option AQuick Check:
dp[3] = 2 matches manual calculation [OK]
- Off-by-one in loop bounds
- Confusing dp[i-j] with dp[j]
Solution
Step 1: Identify loops in the algorithm
The algorithm has an outer loop over n items and an inner loop over capacities from W down to the item's weight, which can be up to W iterations.Step 2: Calculate total operations
Multiplying the loops gives O(n * W) time complexity. Recursive brute force is exponential, and linear or logarithmic complexities are incorrect here.Final Answer:
Option C -> Option CQuick Check:
Nested loops over n and W -> O(n * W) [OK]
- Confusing recursion stack space with time complexity.
def knapsack_space_optimized(weights, values, W):
n = len(weights)
dp = [0] * (W + 1)
for i in range(n):
for w in range(weights[i], W + 1): # Note: iterating forwards
dp[w] = max(dp[w], dp[w - weights[i]] + values[i])
return dp[W]Solution
Step 1: Analyze iteration order in inner loop
The inner loop iterates forwards from weights[i] to W, which causes the current item to be counted multiple times in the same iteration, violating 0/1 knapsack constraints.Step 2: Correct iteration direction
Iterating backwards (from W down to weights[i]) ensures each item is only counted once per capacity, preserving correctness.Final Answer:
Option A -> Option AQuick Check:
Forward iteration causes overcounting items [OK]
- Iterating forwards in dp array updates for 0/1 knapsack.
Solution
Step 1: Check base case initialization
dp[0] must be true to represent sum zero achievable with empty subset; missing this causes no sums to be marked achievable.Step 2: Verify other lines
Loops and return statement are correct; only missing dp[0] initialization breaks correctness.Final Answer:
Option A -> Option AQuick Check:
Without dp[0] = true, dp array never updates correctly [OK]
- Forgetting dp[0] initialization
- Using forward iteration causing overcounting
